Overcriminalization: Attacking a Dangerous Precedent

What happens when the Florida legislature eliminates the centuries-old requirement that the government must prove that an accused person acted with criminal intent before he may be punished as a criminal? It risks making almost anyone a criminal – both those who intend to commit a crime and those who do so by accident. And that’s wrong. It’s wrong as a matter of policy, and it’s wrong as a matter of history.

In high school civics class, and from law-and-order television shows and films, every American has learned that in our criminal justice system a person accused of a crime is always presumed innocent until proven guilty. Similarly, the government bears the burden of proving every element of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt. Likewise, we have also learned that in order to be a criminal one must act with criminal intent – what lawyers call mens rea.

That’s why an act by the Florida legislature is of concern to so many criminal-law experts. The Florida legislature decided in 2002 to eliminate from almost every drug possession case one of the most essential safeguards that the rule of law provides to the innocent. In such cases, the State of Florida need no longer prove that the accused acted with any form of criminal intent. The government need not prove that the individual even knew that what he possessed was drugs in order to send him to decades in prison.
At first blush, that may not sound like a bad thing given the damage drugs and drug trafficking do to America. But as one Louisiana court pointed out in a similar case, it “requires little imagination to visualize a situation in which a third party hands the controlled substance to an unknowing individual who then can be charged . . . and . . . convicted without ever being aware of the nature of the substance he was given.” This would be a pretty easy way for bad guys to set up anyone they did not like.

Anyone who thinks this is far-fetched need only consider the story of Cheye Calvo, the mayor of Berwyn Heights, a small Maryland town just inside Washington’s Capital Beltway. The story made national news because Prince George’s County used a SWAT team to storm through Mayor Calvo’s front door, shoot his two Labrador retrievers, and interrogate the bound and half-naked mayor for two hours while he sat in the presence of his mother-in-law, with the dogs’ bloody carcasses surrounding them. Prince George’s law enforcement conducted the raid because an overnight carrier had delivered a package containing marijuana to Mayor Calvo’s doorstep. Calvo took the package inside with him when he brought his dogs in from a walk. Moments later, the Prince George’s County SWAT team was inside shooting Mayor Calvo’s dogs, seizing the unopened package, and handcuffing the mayor himself.



Sign up for our daily email and get the stories everyone is talking about.


Previous post

Obama on Egypt

Next post

Democracy and Economic Freedom: An Unbeatable Combination for the Middle East

Join the conversation!

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse.